The collocation of these books suggests a moral: it is easier to write well about living authors if they annoy you than if you worship the very paper they write on. Rob Nixon is censorious and lively; Dale Salwak is reverent and laboured. His is the second book in recent memory expressly to demand recognition for Kingsley Amis as a moralist; the other, John McDermott's, is actually called Kingsley Amis: An English Moralist. McDermott says 'moralist' clearly and right away, whereas Salwak's subtitle sounds like one of Amis's phonetic reports on the way a drunken man might have struggled to get the word out. However, both insist on Amis's serious ethical concerns.

LRB 10 September 1992 | PDF Download