In the middle of his new book Michael Baxandall wonders whether the 'complex Newtonian-Lockean sense of how we see', which he has just expertly expounded, provides any 'purchase' on Chardin's painting, A Lady Taking Tea, to which 'our primary explanatory duty is due.' It is bracing to discover that we have this duty but I am puzzled by what exactly needs explanation.

LRB 21 November 1985 | PDF Download